What annealing actually does to brass
Cartridge brass is a copper and zinc alloy, and like any metal, it has a grain structure. When you work your brass, those grains deform, stretch and lock against each other. The metal gets harder and less willing to move. Every firing expands the neck out against the chamber, and every pass through a sizing die squeezes it back down again, so a case neck is worked twice per cycle, every cycle, for its entire life.
If you heat the neck to the right temperature, the grains recrystallise. New, undistorted grains form in place of the worked ones, and the brass returns to something close to its original ductility. Annealing doesn’t soften the case - it resets it. You are putting the neck back to a known state rather than making it soft.
What are the specific benefits of annealing brass?
Consistent neck tension. Work-hardened necks grip the bullet with varying force, because hardness is never uniform across a batch. A properly annealed neck grips the same way every time, which is why annealing shows up on a chronograph before it shows up on a target.
Repeatable sizing. Hard brass springs back after sizing, and it springs back by an amount that depends on how hard it has become. That makes shoulder bump unpredictable. Annealed brass springs back consistently, so the shoulder ends up where the die put it.
Case life. The obvious one. Necks that are never annealed eventually split, and expensive match brass retired for split necks is just a waste of money.
Why anneal only the neck and shoulder?
The head and web of the case must stay hard. That is the part holding back chamber pressure, and hard brass is what contains it. A case head that has been annealed is dangerous - and it will likely fail without warning.
This is why you need a dedicated annealing machine - because if you can’t fully control where the heat goes, or how far down the case it travels once you stop applying it, it’s going to fail at some point, and when it does fail, it won’t fail safely. Heat conducts along a case after the flame comes off, and it does so faster in a small case with thin walls than in a large one.
This is why we really don’t recommend annealing your brass by putting it in the oven or by using a blowtorch - you’ve got no control at all where the heat goes. With a dedicated annealer, you do.
Torch, salt bath or induction annealing
Torch and drill. The cheapest approach, and it does work if you are careful and consistent. The
problem is what you are measuring against. You are judging by colour, by a count, or by
Tempilaq, and all three vary with ambient light, torch pressure, how long the case sat before
you started and how tired you are by case two hundred. Heat also keeps travelling after you pull
the case away, so the result depends partly on what you do next.
Salt bath. More repeatable than a torch, because the bath is at a known temperature and the
immersion is timed. It brings its own problems: molten salt at over 500 degrees farenheit on a reloading bench, cases that must be perfectly dry going in, and disposal afterwards.
Induction. Heats the neck and shoulder directly, electromagnetically, to a defined energy over a
defined time. There is no flame, no ambient variable and no judgement call. Every case in the
batch receives the same treatment, which is the entire point of annealing in a precision context.
At Creedmoor Sports - we stock induction annealers only. If you are looking for a torch and drill or salt bath annealer, we do not sell those.
The AMP (Annealing Made Perfect) system
Annealing Made Perfect is the standard reference in induction annealing, and the Mark 2 DB is the most up-to-date machine. It anneals everything from .17 Hornet to 50 BMG on a larger inductor with significantly more output power, with a ceramic heat shield inside the inductor to manage heat and cooling good enough for near indefinite run time on smaller cases such as .223. The pilot boss is user replaceable if it is ever cross threaded or damaged, and the machine carries a three year warranty.
Pilots
Pilots are cartridge specific and they are not included with the machine. You need the correct pilot for the cartridge or cartridge family you intend to anneal. There is a pilot selector on the product page to identify the right number.
Shell holder grips
The grip holds standard press type shell holders from Redding, RCBS and Hornady, so you most likely already own what goes in it. One grip is supplied with each machine; we stock replacements, and a separate 50 BMG version.
The Creedmoor AMP Pilot Holder
Once you anneal more than two or three cartridges you accumulate pilots, and loose pilots on a bench are annoying. Our AMP Pilot Holder takes ten pilots plus the brass shell holder grip, with the holes cut to hold each pilot upright so you can see what you have and change over quickly. It is a minor thing, and it is the sort of minor thing that comes from actually using the machine.
The ARC Ultimate Annealer
At the high volume end, the ARC Ultimate is a bench top induction annealer supplied complete with a case feeder and automatic feed system, so cases run through without being handled individually. It uses MHT technology to control the annealing temperature precisely at a specified location on the neck, shoulder or body of the case, which is a level of control beyond simply annealing the neck.
How often should you anneal?
For match brass where velocity spread matters, annealing every firing is common, and it is the only way to keep neck tension constant across the life of the batch. For general precision loading, every three to five firings is normal. For plinking or practice brass you intend to discard, annealing isn’t really worth the time.
Anneal before sizing rather than after. The point is to have the neck in a known, uniform state as it goes into the die, so that spring-back is consistent and the shoulder finishes where the die put it. Annealing after sizing leaves you with a neck that was hard when it was worked and soft afterwards - which is the wrong way round.
There are signs that you have left it too long between annealings - if you notice velocity spread creeping up across a batch that used to be tight, seating force that varies between case to case, and stiffer or inconsistent chambering. By the time you get a split neck, it’s just too late.
Frequently asked questions about case annealing (FAQs)
Is annealing brass worth it?
If you shoot for score or reload expensive match brass, yes. The measurable gain is consistent neck tension and lower velocity spread, and the secondary gain is case life. If you shoot practice ammunition from mixed brass, it is not worth the equipment.
How often should you anneal cases?
Every firing for match brass, every three to five firings for general precision work. Consistency of interval matters as much as the interval itself, because brass annealed on different schedules within one batch is no longer a matched batch.
Do you anneal before or after sizing?
Before. The neck needs to be in a uniform state going into the die so spring-back is consistent and shoulder bump repeats.
Can you over-anneal brass?
Yes. Too much heat, or heat that travels too far down the case, leaves the neck excessively soft and can reach the web, which is a safety problem rather than an accuracy one. This is the main argument for induction over flame: the energy delivered is defined rather than judged.
Do you need to quench annealed brass?
No. Brass does not harden by quenching the way steel does, so dropping cases into water changes nothing metallurgically. It is sometimes done to stop heat travelling further down the case, but with induction annealers the heat is controlled at source and quenching is unnecessary.
Do I need a pilot for every cartridge?
You need the correct AMP pilot for each cartridge or cartridge family you anneal, and pilots are not included with the machine. Use the pilot selector to identify the right number before ordering.
Can you anneal new brass?
You can, and some shooters do it to bring a new lot to the same known state as their existing annealed brass. It is not necessary otherwise, since new brass has not yet been work hardened.